3 minutes reading time (691 words)

We Invested $27,000 In 3 Large-Cap Growth Index Funds For 5 Months. One Stood Out.

Your investment portfolio should include securities from all major asset classes for true diversification, including U.S. large-cap, mid-cap, small-cap, and international equities, among others. How does the index fund investor pick a winning large-cap strategy? This 5-month investing experiment should provide some help.



We conducted a 5-month experiment from July 25, 2019 to December 31, 2019, where we invested (hypothetically) $27,000 in each of 3 large-cap passive funds: an S&P 500 index fund (FXAIX: Fidelity 500 Index Fund), a large-cap growth index fund (FSPGX: Fidelity Large-Cap Growth Index Fund), and a large growth technology ETF (FTEC: Fidelity MSCI Information Technology Index ETF). These are three extremely cheap index funds with low expense ratios (ER): FXAIX, ER 0.02%), FSPGX, ER 0.04%; FTEC, ER 0.08%. The results are shown below. 

Fund Ticker Purchased NAV
Final NAV
NAV AppreciationNAV Appreciation Earnings
​​FXAIX $​105.23 ​$​112.02 $​6.79$​​1742.20
​FSPGX​$​​16.35$​​17.51$​​1.16$​1915.60
FTEC​$​​65.98​$​​72.48$​​6.50$​2659.90

Table 1. This table represents the scenarios mentioned above. We used (hypothetically) $27,000 to purchase the funds at their net asset values (NAVs) on 7/25/19: FXAIX, 257 shares; FSPGX, 1651 shares; FTEC, 409 shares.  We used the final NAV after the market closed on 12/31/19. Please note: NAV appreciation = final NAV - purchased NAV; NAV Appreciation Earnings = # shares x NAV appreciation.



Fund Ticker Distribution Per Share Distribution Earnings Total Earnings (Appreciation + Distribution)Final Invested Balance 
​FXAIX ​$​1.253​ ​$​​321.50 ​$​​2140.65​$​29140.65​
​FSPGX​$​​0.13​$​​214.68​$​​2262.39​$​​29262.39
​FTEC​$​​0.376​$​​153.86​​$​2813.76​$​29813.76

Table 2. This table shows distribution and earnings for the 3 funds. Distribution Per Share = dividends + short and longterm capital gains. All dividend information is obtained from DividendInvestor; Distribution Earnings  = Distribution Per Share x # shares; Total earnings = Distribution Earnings +  NAV Appreciation Earnings. These calculations do not take into account any dividend reinvestment, taxes, fees or any expenses charged during this 5-month experiment. 



Results analysis and discussion

All three passive funds delivered stellar earnings during this 5-month investing experiment. As table 1 shows,the large growth technology ETF (FTEC) delivered the highest earnings from capital appreciation ($2659.90), followed by the large-cap growth index fund ($1915.60) and then the S&P 500 index fund ($1742.20). The S&P 500 index fund paid more dividends per share, $1.253, than either the technology ETF, $0.376, or the large-cap growth index fund, $0.13,  (See table 2). As a large blend fund, a fund that includes both growth and value stocks, FXAIX, like other index funds that track the S&P 500 index, tends to have higher dividend yields compared to large-cap growth funds. Large-cap growth funds typically seek capital appreciation over dividends. At the end of this 5-month experiment, the final invested balances for FTEC, FSPGX, and FXAIX were $29,813.76, $29,262.39, and $29,140.65, respectively.



Key takeaways

Passive index investing is becoming a widely used investing strategy for both the newbie investor and even more experienced investors. With this style of investing, investors purchase funds (index funds or exchange-traded funds) that track a representative index, such as the S&P 500. If you are looking for a strong passive fund to meet your portfolio's large-cap needs, either of these 3 funds will suit your investing needs. All three funds are ultra-cheap, as evidenced by their low expense ratios.

If you want to get a piece of the largest 500 companies and relish dividends, the Fidelity 500 Index Fund, FXAIX, may be right for you. Those who prefer capital appreciation over dividends may find FTEC a more suitable option. However, with FTEC, keep in mind that this large growth ETF is tech-heavy and less diversified than the other two index funds. Its two largest holdings, Apple (18.51%) and Microsoft (15.95%), comprise more than 34% of that ETF (as of 1/3/20). Proceed with caution with FTEC. 



​The bottom line

Which one of these 3 cheap index funds would you use to suit your portfolio's large-cap needs? Let us know in the comment section below. Please share this article. If you are interested in submitting a guest post, please click here. Here are a few other articles you may find useful: 3 simple ways to handle stock market volatility | 4 smart ways to both invest and pay down student debt | A simple portfolio to supercharge your returns | How to invest $50.

Become a fan. Subscribe.

5 Smart Investing Money Moves To Make In 2020 To M...
A Simple Free Money Secret That Every Investor Sho...

Related Posts

 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Thursday, 20 February 2020

Captcha Image

Recent Blog Posts

A Top Investment Blog

INVESTING POLL

You are given $10,000 to invest in one of the securities listed below. What's your buy?

OUR LATEST TWEETS

Most Popular Posts

ABOUT US

Our mission is to empower people to become investors and start building wealth. We provide investment knowledge that will give people the confidence to start investing and building a better financial future.

invest now . investing quiz

Become a fan

INVEST WITH SOFI

Get $100 worth of your favorite stocks. Build your portfolio with stocks or ETFs. Invest Now.